Policymakers have tried tax cuts to compensate losses in market income growth. That strategy has failed: Why predistribution policies need to be at the forefront of any inequality agenda

Key takeaways

  • For the past 45 years, policymakers have attempted to reduce income inequality by relying more on cutting federal taxes rather than boosting transfers like Medicaid.
  • But the tax and transfer system has fallen short of this goal—narrowing the inequality gap from 32% to 20% between 1979 and 2022, only by about one-third of the total gap. At the same time, policies were passed that ripped away any bit of bargaining power or leverage typical workers had in labor markets.
  • Since the data show that we can’t tax and transfer our way out of inequality, the final option remains to change policies that affect the distribution of market income so that inequality doesn’t get too large in the first place.

Tax cuts have become the single most namechecked policy in D.C. This has long been the priority of Republican policymaking. Post 1979 though, a nontrivial share of Democrats has also adopted the neoliberal view that markets should be allowed to generate more inequality in the pursuit of economic prosperity. They reasoned that policy could limit the downsides by compensating those on the losing end of higher market-driven inequality by making taxes, social insurance, such as Social Security, and public transfers, such as Medicaid, more equalizing. This strategy is often shorthanded as “compensating the losers”—those who have been left worse off.

For the past 45 years, to the degree policymakers have aimed to compensate for rising market-based inequality, they have relied more on cutting federal taxes rather than boosting transfers. They cut federal taxes for middle-income families significantly— by about a third. Yet, even with these cuts, middle-class economic security has not substantially improved over time, and much of market-driven inequality has gone uncompensated. Even as support for more universal public benefits has grown in recent years among some Democrats, too many in Washington still have an ingrained reflex of “maybe a tax cut will do it”?

In this post we probe why “compensating the losers” through redistribution failed to reduce economic inequality on its own. While policymakers increased transfers and cut middle-class taxes, the transfers programs were targeted mostly for elderly and low-income households, and the policies that were passed ripped away any bit of bargaining power or leverage typical workers had in labor markets. These policies ultimately supported employers putting a lot less into typical workers’ paychecks, even as the federal government took a bit less out.

Read more

Sixteen states will raise their minimum wages on January 1, lifting pay for over 6.6 million workers

Key takeaways

  • More than 6.6 million workers will get a raise starting January 1 as 16 states raise their minimum wages.
  • The increases will range from $0.26 an hour in Nebraska to $1.27 an hour in Michigan.
  • Michigan will be the latest state to reach at least a $15 minimum wage, joining 17 states and Washington, D.C. More workers will live in states with a $15 or greater minimum wage than in states with a $7.25 minimum wage.
  • Once again, localities in Washington state will have the highest minimum wages in the country. Tukwila, for example, will raise its minimum wage to $22.45, while the city of Burien could see a new rate of $22.49 if ongoing legal proceedings are resolved and the current law is upheld.
  • Raising the minimum wage is a simple, yet powerful way to make life more affordable for millions of working people. State and federal policymakers should ensure wage floors meet the needs of all workers.

Sixteen states will increase their minimum wages on January 1, boosting earnings for more than 6.6 million workers by a total of nearly $4.3 billion (see Figure A and Table 2). In addition, 48 cities and counties across the country will raise their minimum wages, lifting pay for even more workers.

These increases are happening because state and local lawmakers, and in some cases voters, took action to help combat affordability challenges for low-wage workers across the country. With this month’s elections dramatically reshaping legislatures across the country, workers in many more states could see their paychecks grow if incoming lawmakers similarly act to raise their state wage floors.

Read more

The new Congress can’t tackle affordability without raising the minimum wage

Affordability—or the lack thereof—has dominated the political debate in the U.S. and was the driving concern for voters in the midterm election. And for good reason. Across the country, too many families are struggling to make ends meet, and their message at the ballot box was clear. They want change, and they expect their elected representatives to deliver it. As the new Congress considers an affordability agenda to help working families, lawmakers must understand that a key reason paychecks no longer stretch to cover the essentials is suppressed pay—not prices alone.Read more

A hot economy for billionaires, but not for everyone else: People are right to feel cold about the economy

Key takeaways 

  • Public sentiment about the economy and headline indicators seem at odds with each other again. Decent topline numbers reported in recent data releases are coinciding with growing dissatisfaction from households. 
  • Unlike earlier this decade, however, this divergence is easily explained since there is really only one source of strength in the economy right now—spending associated with the great race to build out AI tools. 
  • The spending associated with this race concentrates its benefits narrowly in the economy while imposing costs broadly on typical families. And it has done little to boost the wider labor market, where softness has led to consistent decelerating wage growth over the past year. 

Starting this summer and even continuing past the midterm elections, President Trump has been trying to convince Americans that the United States “has the hottest economy in the world.” And by some measures the U.S. economy does seem pretty warm: The Federal Reserve raised interest rates six weeks ago in response to stubbornly high inflation. While they held off raising rates at last week’s meeting, there were two dissenters arguing for higher rates.

Further, third-quarter growth in gross domestic product (GDP) picked up to 3.4%, after averaging 2% for a few years, and both private investment and consumption growth were strong.

Yet the public seems unimpressed by all of this—the 12-month average of the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment series hit its lowest point in history in the past month. 

This all raises the question of whether this is just one more period of divergence between perceptions and hard economic data that has been a feature of the economy since COVID-19. The short answer is “no.” Unlike in 2023 and 2024, the hard economic data just one step below the headlines actually provide plenty of reasons explaining why the public is sour on the economy. Specifically: 

  • All the heat in the economy is coming from the race to build data centers and other investments in artificial intelligence (AI).
    • Boom times and a modern gold rush for billionaires shouldn’t be expected to make normal people all that happy—particularly when the gold the billionaires are looking for is technology that will steal jobs from typical workers. 
  • The labor market—where normal people earn their incomes—is not hot. And it’s cooling noticeably. Nominal wage growth is now consistent with below 2% price inflation, yet inflation is a lot higher than that.
    • This labor market coolness is driven in part by the damaging effects of the Trump administration’s policy of cruel and arbitrary mass deportations. Growth in the U.S. labor force has slowed significantly in the past 15–18 months, and cities subject to large-scale ICE operations have suffered demonstrable economic damage. 
  • Despite a cool labor market and weak wage growth that should be pulling down prices, inflation has risen sharply over the past year. The sources of these price increases are obviously linked to Trump administration policy choices—most notably their bombing of Iran.

Read more

The school bus driver shortage is worsening as wages fall once again

Key findings:

  • Reversing modest improvements last year, school bus driver employment levels have fallen again and are now 15.0% below 2019 levels.
  • School bus driver hourly wages have dropped 0.7% since last September after accounting for inflation, while hourly pay for other bus drivers has held steady, making school bus jobs less competitive than other driving jobs.
  • These drops in employment and wages reflect profound funding challenges schools are facing, which have been exacerbated by the Trump administration’s attacks on public education, cuts to Medicaid and SNAP enacted in the 2025 Republican tax and spending bill, and ongoing state and local attacks on school funding.

The school year began once again with many public schools reporting they’re struggling to hire and retain school bus drivers. Indeed, our analysis of the latest data finds that the longstanding school bus driver shortage is getting worse. K–12 school bus driver employment fell by 5.0% over the past year and is now 15.0% below 2019 staffing levels.

This reversal from the modest gain in school bus driver employment that occurred in 2025 is likely tied to the decline in inflation-adjusted hourly wages for school bus drivers since last fall. Notably, this contrasts with hourly pay for bus drivers outside of schools, which at least kept pace with inflation.

Public schools are facing daunting budget challenges resulting from the expiration of pandemic-era federal funds, the expansion of private school voucher programs, the Trump administration’s dismantling of the Department of Education, and the 2025 Republican tax and spending bill’s massive cuts to Medicaid and SNAP, which directly impact public school funding. Funding losses combined with significantly higher costs—including the diesel fuel that most school buses use—spell trouble for school districts trying to maintain adequate staffing. A shortage of school bus drivers leads to route cuts, delays, increased safety risks, and other hurdles for students and their families, as well as higher traffic congestion during student commute periods. Without adequate funding for public education and competitive pay for essential public school staff, entire communities suffer.

Read more

The economics of deficits, debt, and interest rates: Part 2: Structural deficits today are too large

This is part two of a series on the economics of debt, deficits, and today’s high interest rates—and how policymakers should respond. Read part one here. 

The effects of deficits and debt on the broader economy are largely straightforward—with one big exception: They differ radically depending on whether the economy is operating near its productive potential or is instead operating well below it (which occurs most notably during recessions).Read more

The economics of deficits, debt, and interest rates: Part 1: What rising interest rates say about today’s structural deficits

This is part one of a series on the economics of debt, deficits, and today’s high interest rates—and how policymakers should respond. Read part two here. 

Long-term interest rates have been rising steadily over the past six months and have now reached their highest levels since before the Great Recession of 2008. These higher rates, combined with inflation that remains above the Federal Reserve’s 2% target, are likely driven in part by unsustainably high federal budget deficits.Read more

Rest in power Dolores Huerta: La lucha sigue! The fight for equality and dignity for farmworkers continues

Yesterday, the world lost Dolores Huerta, a pioneering labor leader, organizer, and activist who made her mark on the world by advocating for some of poorest and most exploited workers in the United States: the farmworkers who cultivate, pick, and package the food we all eat. She continued fighting for social change until her death at age 96.

Her lasting impact on the lives of farmworkers is almost impossible to overstate. Farmworkers are notoriously some of the most difficult workers to organize because of extreme poverty and language and immigration status barriers, and because farm jobs are seasonal and unstable. Nevertheless, Huerta set out to organize them by starting the Agricultural Workers Association in 1960 and two years later co-founding the United Farm Workers Association, which became the United Farm Workers (UFW) in 1972—one of the few farmworker unions in the country. She masterminded successful strikes and boycotts against wealthy farm owners and businesses and negotiated the first-ever collective bargaining agreement with an agricultural employer, which won farmworkers long-overdue raises and newfound benefits.

Her advocacy extended far beyond the fields and negotiating rooms, helping win major policies that reshaped the legal landscape for farmworkers in California and showed the rest of the country what was possible. Perhaps the most notable is the 1975 Agricultural Labor Relations Act (ALRA), which gave farmworkers in California the right to organize and bargain collectively. The ALRA also created the Agricultural Labor Relations Board, which operates similarly to the federal National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) by conducting union elections and adjudicating unfair labor practice charges—standing in for the NLRB because farmworkers are excluded from the federal law that governs labor rights. Throughout her life, Huerta also pushed for policies that would, for example, protect farmworkers from pesticide exposure, provide disability insurance for injured farmworkers, and expand voter and language access for Latinas and Latinos.

Read more

Labor and human rights in the global economy: USMCA’s labor chapter must be strengthened

This is a guest blog from Owen Herrnstadt, former Chief of Staff of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers and former member of the Board of Directors of the U.S. Export-Import Bank. 

International labor and human rights standards are widely recognized but rarely enforced. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the conventions and declarations of the International Labor Organization (ILO), the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) guidelines, and the performance standards of international financial institutions all set out expectations for how workers should be treated, yet each lacks a meaningful mechanism for compelling compliance. Trade law has emerged as a possible exception. Renegotiation of the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) offers an opportunity to significantly strengthen efforts to effectively enforce labor and human rights in a regional trade agreement. 

While USMCA’s labor chapter and its annexes—including the Rapid Response Labor Mechanism (RRM)—represent the most ambitious labor enforcement architecture in any U.S. trade agreement, serious criticism remains over its impact on improving labor and human rights. Mexico’s reforms have not gone far enough, implementation has raised serious questions, the RRM—while representing a significant step forward—is narrow, slow, and procedurally burdensome, and the wage and trade balance outcomes the agreement was meant to improve have not moved in the right direction.

Read more

Voters in Colorado and Florida face major tax questions on the November ballot

Key Takeaways:

  • Colorado Amendment 87 would help fix a structural funding problem that has undermined the state’s public services for 35 years. The measure would modestly raise taxes on the top 3% of taxpayers while generating $2 billion in revenue.
  • Florida Amendment 3 would devastate public services across the state. It would cut annual local government revenue by an estimated $12 billion, equivalent to 17% of statewide local government compensation. This translates to 123,000 jobs at risk of being cut from local government payrolls across the state.

Lots of media attention around the upcoming midterm elections is understandably focused on which party will win control of Congress, as well as the many state legislative chambers and governorships that are up for grabs. However, there are also over 150 state ballot measures going before voters next month, some of which will be tremendously consequential in shaping state economies for years to come. Two such proposals warrant greater attention: Amendment 87 in Colorado and Amendment 3 in Florida. Both would be transformative for their respective states—the former in positive ways, the latter in catastrophic ones.Read more