Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee member Bill Cassidy, R-La., pressed former U.S. Department of Labor chief economist Heidi Shierholz on the implications of a chart showing parallels between trends in union membership rates and the percentage of income going to the top 10% of earners going back to 1917. Shierholz, now the director of policy at the progressive Economic Policy Institute, had cited the chart in testimony supporting the Protecting the Right to Organize Act, which would make it easier for workers to form unions.
Cassidy, who was a medical doctor before entering politics, suggested these trends have more to do with the movement of high-paying manufacturing jobs overseas than legal roadblocks to unionizing, quipping “we contrast between association and causation” in medicine. Shierholz conceded the chart showed a “rough relationship” but insisted workers’ difficulties forming unions under current law have played a key role in rising income inequality.
“Rigorous research that digs in and really gets at causality does show that about a third of the increase in inequality between typical workers and workers at the high end over the last 40 years was due to the decline in unionization,” Shierholz said. “The whole rise in inequality is not due to unionization, but a big chunk of it [is].”
Shierholz was one of four witnesses who testified before the HELP Committee on Thursday during a more than two-hour hearing on the PRO Act, which is pending in the Senate.
…
Shortly after Shierholz’s exchange with Cassidy, Sen. Robert Marshall, R-Kan., suggested declining membership has more to do with unions’ failings than gaps in labor law. Marshall asked Obama administration National Labor Relations Board Chairman Mark Gaston Pearce why the government should “restructure law in unions’ favor when unions are failing to make a compelling case?”