Report | Artificial intelligence (AI)

FAQ AI and the economy: Your questions, answered

This FAQ addresses the potential effect of artificial intelligence (AI) on the U.S. economy, particularly on labor markets. Many recent concerns about advances in AI—for example, its implications for national security, cybersecurity, or media disinformation—are largely outside our areas of expertise. But we do have considerable expertise regarding AI’s potential effect on labor markets and the broader impacts of technological change on the economy.

Further, many of AI’s potential effects on the economy are largely distinct from its consequences in these other areas, making the economic effects amenable to separate, granular analysis. For example, if poorly regulated and recklessly deployed AI systems lead to disruptive cybersecurity incidents, this could obviously have some economic effects (imagine a large bank suffering a cyberattack and depositors’ funds being frozen or inaccessible for a time). But regulatory failures and irresponsible management of AI systems that lead to cyberattacks do not really signal anything about the economic potential for AI tools to replace human labor at large scale or about how a rapid evaporation of AI investment or stock market gains would ripple through the economy. Nor does the right policy to mitigate possible cybersecurity or disinformation problems exacerbated by AI have much at all to do with the optimal policy to ensure working families’ prosperity and economic security in an age of AI.

Across all realms of AI policy, much attention has been paid to regulations that are specifically tailored to AI. This might be appropriate in some fields. However, we suggest that not enough attention has been paid to simply applying protections, norms, and institutions that predate AI to its uses. For example, tort law already makes it possible to hold companies liable for harms their products create. While the application of these existing legal remedies to AI hacking incidents could potentially be clarified, it doesn’t seem to require a huge new field of law or legislation to make this possible. Further, we should significantly strengthen the application and enforcement of existing protections for workers. For example, employers should be held liable when they discriminate against workers, rather than being able to evade accountability because the discriminatory impact stemmed from their use of an algorithm or other automated system.

This notion that existing best practices, policies, and ideas are likely to be the best solutions to the problems AI may cause holds particularly true when it comes to its economic effects. The single largest concern expressed in this realm is AI’s potential to permanently displace very large amounts of human labor in a short period of time, causing economy-wide joblessness and wage declines. This FAQ will examine the economic evidence surrounding many of these concerns, but one key conclusion to state here is that even if such a scenario seemed plausible, it is highly unlikely that policies tailored specifically to AI tools’ potential uses in workplaces could ever keep up with, let alone proactively block, the ways that millions of private-sector firms are adopting these tools. What would reduce the most harm in such scenarios is implementing ideas already firmly on the policy agenda for many: keep the macroeconomy well managed and unemployment rates very low; provide effective protection for workers’ rights to form unions and bargain in the workplace over issues like how technology is implemented; offer a more protective social safety net that makes spells of joblessness less devastating for workers experiencing them; and implement progressive taxes—particularly higher tax rates on income derived from capital.

It is understandable that people are anxious about what AI could do to workers’ jobs and wages in coming years; the U.S. labor market has been rigged by policy for decades to make most workers insecure and keep their wages suppressed. AI deployed into this rigged labor market, as is happening currently, is unlikely to provide much benefit to most workers and could inject more churn and uncertainty. But making the policy changes noted above and deploying AI in a high-road economy where policy forces labor markets to perform better could allay many of these worries. In fact, if power were rebalanced in our economy to ensure workers are protected and empowered, AI might deliver real tangible benefits to most workers in the form of faster wage growth.

To be clear, arguing that broad, pre-existing ideas for how to unrig labor markets and generate shared prosperity are the best response to the economic concerns of AI does not mean we’re not taking AI “seriously” or recognizing its potential harms across many other realms. Instead, our recommendation stems from granular analysis of how AI might affect the economy and labor markets.

How should we think about AI’s likely effects on jobs and wages?

The effect of AI on the wages and employment of typical U.S. workers will, like most technological advances, hinge almost entirely on the broader economic, social, and political context. Crucially, the U.S. labor market has been largely rigged by policy to suppress wages and opportunities for most workers. In this context, there is little upside for U.S. workers from widespread deployment of AI tools. There are also widespread fears that AI might threaten jobs and wages on a large scale. But were the labor market substantially unrigged, AI tools could well raise the living standards of working people. Nothing inherent to AI lets us forecast its potential effects on U.S. workers, for good or bad. This will be determined by policy.

What’s AI’s most immediate threat to the U.S. economy?

AI-related spending accounts for roughly half of U.S. growth in recent quarters—a narrow and fragile base for economic growth. That spending comes from two sources: (1) tangible investment in data centers, hardware, and research, and (2) consumption financed by the AI-driven stock bubble. Both spending flows could reverse quickly if expectations change about the future profitability of AI tools. If this reversal happens, the economy may well enter recession unless policymakers react nimbly and smartly.

Is the current fixation on AI the first time a technology-driven stock market bubble has threatened the broader economy?

Today’s AI boom bears striking parallels to the internet build-out and stock market bubble of the late 1990s. That episode clearly led to a stock market bubble, and the resulting deflation of that bubble led to a very stubborn recession. But the late 1990s boom also gave the U.S. labor market four to five very strong years before the bubble burst—something the current AI frenzy has largely failed to do.

Is AI inevitably bad for the jobs and wages of typical workers over the longer run?

There’s no obvious reason to think so. Economists’ best summary measure of how rapidly technological change is moving forward is the pace of productivity growth—growth in the average output and income created in an hour of work. Throughout history, periods of fast productivity growth (that is, periods of rapid technological advance) have been good, not bad, for the wages and jobs of typical workers. What has overwhelmingly determined how workers fare is policy, not the pace or nature of technological change, and there is no sign yet that AI will break that pattern. Current policy is notably bad for workers’ jobs and wages and should be fixed, but that poor policy environment predates AI by decades.

Won’t AI automate many jobs away?

AI will likely destroy some specific jobs through automation—but it is also highly likely to create jobs more broadly over time by boosting incomes for those in the non-automated sectors. How much any particular group of workers suffers when displaced from their jobs will be determined by policy decisions. Throughout U.S. history, we have generally been terrible at managing these transitions in worker-friendly ways. It would obviously be better if we changed that and put in place the policy supports workers need to get through them.

If AI can both create and destroy jobs, does this mean policymakers can totally ignore its effects?

No. If anything, the opposite is true: Policymakers should be doing far more to protect working families from the hardship and uncertainty of earning a living in labor markets that are volatile and offer little protection. If AI-induced technological change turns out to be large and causes significant job displacement, it will hit a U.S. labor market with few worker protections and create real pockets of concentrated harm—as every other economic change of the past several decades has. But the main driver of this harm is the weakness of U.S. labor market protections, not the specifics of the technology.

Will AI lead to mass unemployment across the U.S. economy?

Almost surely not. The historical evidence is clear that business cycles with faster productivity growth see lower unemployment, not higher. And the ease with which AI or any capital investment can substitute for human labor at scale is often overstated.

How much might AI boost productivity growth—and has the U.S. labor market ever absorbed that fast a productivity acceleration before?

Most credible estimates project that AI could boost productivity growth over the next decade by an average of 0.5–1.5 percentage points per year. Even at the high end of 1.5 percentage points per year, that implies an acceleration of productivity growth that the U.S. economy has easily absorbed in the past with no labor market distress. In fact, periods of productivity acceleration have been good for U.S. workers; it is productivity slowdowns that have coincided with bad outcomes.