Over the last several years, EPI has developed a wide body of research on collective bargaining and unions. For instance, the statement in support of the Employee Free Choice Act by EPI President Lawrence Mishel, along with Richard Freeman of Harvard and Frank Levy of MIT, cited the recent unprecedented growth of inequality in household income and the urgent need to give workers more bargaining power. Forty prominent economists signed the original statement, including three Nobel Prize winners, agreeing that the reform would be an overall benefit to the economy and would provide a boost to workers when they need it most. Other economists later added their voices by signing the same statement, which resulted in close to 200 more signatories. The statement is available in both its original and updated versions. EPI also prepared a question-and-answer document to explain the Employee Free Choice Act.
Over the years, EPI’s staff economists and associated scholars have conducted extensive research on unions and the economy. Here is a partial list of significant recent studies and analysis:
- Unions, inequality, and faltering middle-class wages
By Lawrence Mishel, 2012
This report previews The State of Working America, 12th Edition, presenting a detailed analysis of the impact of unionization on wages and benefits and on wage inequality.
- The compensation penalty of “right-to-work” laws
By Heidi Shierholz and Elise Gould, 2011
This report directly examines the impact of RTW on the wages and benefits received by workers, both union and nonunion. The authors examine differences in the wages and benefits workers receive in RTW and non-RTW states. Among the findings: wages in RTW states are 3.2 percent lower than those in non-RTW states, and the rate of employer-sponsored pensions is 4.8 percentage points lower in RTW states.
- Business Success and First Contract Arbitration
By Ross Eisenbrey and Patrick Eagan-Van Meter, 2010
This report draws evidence from Canada to defend first-contract arbitration and show how it could help workers collectively bargain for that first contract. Business lobbyists and conservatives like Newt Gingrich have tried to scare the American people away from first contract arbitration with the myth that “many businesses would close, millions of jobs would be lost, and unemployment would rise significantly.” 1 The rhetoric is alarming, but the data show that First Contract Arbitration does not drive companies out of business.
- No Holds Barred: The Intensification of Employer Opposition to Organizing
By Kate Bronfenbrenner, 2009
Co-published by American Rights at Work and EPI, this study reveals that private-sector employer opposition to workers’ efforts to form unions has intensified and become more punitive than in the past. Employers are more than twice as likely to use 10 or more tactics—including threats of and actual firings—in their campaigns to thwart workers’ organizing efforts. Today’s anti-union activities include a greater focus than in the past on more coercive and punitive tactics designed to intensely monitor and punish union activity. EPI published several other studies by Bronfenbrenner covering earlier comparable surveys.
- Still Open for Business: Unionization Has No Causal Effect on Firm Closures
By John DiNardo, 2009
DiNardo, a University of Michigan professor and research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research, offers overwhelming evidence that unionization does not cause businesses to fail.
- Squandering the Blue Collar Advantage
By Josh Bivens, 2009
Bivens shows why unions are not to blame for the loss of U.S. manufacturing jobs, and that in fact, the real culprits are manipulated currency rates that make U.S.-made goods overly expensive. A dysfunctional health care system that burdens responsible employers with outsized costs, and high executive and managerial salaries, also contribute to any lack of competitiveness.
- Organizing Prosperity
By Matt Vidal with David Kusnet, 2009
Using 12 case studies from a variety of industries, including nursing, meatpacking, and janitorial, the authors show how unions can benefit workers and communities while making companies more productive. They also illustrate the damage inflicted when union representation is removed.
- How Unions Can Help Restore the Middle Class
By Paula Voos, 2009
This testimony before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions outlined the importance of unions to the economic interests of workers, including common benefits like raising the wages and fringe benefits of employees, reducing income inequality both within unionized firms and across entire industries, and increasing the retention of skilled employees. Voos, an EPI Research Associate, worked closely with EPI staff in developing her testimony.
- The State of Working America 2008/2009 (excerpts from select chapters)
By Lawrence Mishel, Jared Bernstein, and Heidi Shierholz
This signature publication by EPI, which has documented the economic well-being of American workers since 1988, contains a wealth of information on union benefits for members and non-members, especially for immigrants, African-Americans, Hispanics and Asians.
- Work That Works: An Agenda for Shared Prosperity Forum
Paul Krugman (Keynote Speaker) et al, 2007
This forum, the second in a two-year Agenda for Shared Prosperity initiative that laid the groundwork for much of EPI’s work today, featured proposals to remove the obstacles that increasingly disconnect working Americans from the rewards of their work. Many of the papers described below were released in conjunction with the forum. Paul Krugman, economist and New York Times columnist, delivered the keynote address on Politics, Policy and Inequality.
Krugman outlined the economic trends over the previous decades that led to rising inequality, and offered steps that could be taken to reverse these trends, including strengthening the labor movement.
- The Right to Organize, Freedom, and the Middle Class Squeeze
By Lawrence Mishel, 2007
Testimony before the U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions on March 27, 2007 about the importance of unions for American workers. Mishel explained how unions strengthen our economy as well as our democracy, and how throughout our history, unions have made the United States a fairer, more productive and healthier society. The passage of EFCA, Mishel advised, would help restore the purchasing power of average Americans and lift the living standards of those who have endured the middle class squeeze.
- Unions, the Economy, and Employee Free Choice
By Harley Shaiken, 2007
Shaiken, a professor at UC Berkeley, found that, “The yawning gap between the robust demand to join unions and the anemic membership numbers reflects the fact that, for many Americans, joining a union has become a risk rather than a right.”
- Do Workers Still Want Unions? More Than Ever
By Richard Freeman, 2007
In this paper, Freeman, a noted labor economist at Harvard University, writes that an overwhelming majority of workers say in surveys that they want a stronger collective voice on the job, and believe that a union would be good for their firm as well.
- A New Social Contract: Restoring Dignity and Balance to the Workplace
By Thomas Kochan and Beth Shulman, 2007
The authors note that at a time of soaring productivity, workers were not sharing in the profits. “People are working harder and smarter, but they are not sharing in the gains from their efforts.” They call for new laws to protect the right to join a union and bargain a contract.
- How Unions Help All Workers
By Lawrence Mishel and Matthew Walters, 2003
This briefing paper made the case for how unions have a substantial impact on the compensation and work lives of both unionized and non-unionized workers.
EPI provides several graphs and the associated data related to unions on its State of Working America website.
1. Gingrich, Newt. 2009. “Arbitration the Real Threat in EFCA.” The American Enterprise Institute, 22 April.