As the Trump administration prepares to release a new rule that will expand misclassification of workers as independent contractors, a new Economic Policy Institute brief explains what state policymakers can do to protect workers from misclassification.
Misclassification is a pervasive and widespread problem: as many as 10–30% of employers misclassify their workers. Workers misclassified as independent contractors lose critical protections, benefits, and labor rights including the minimum wage, overtime pay, unemployment insurance, and the right to form a union. Additionally, these workers bear the full financial costs of Social Security and Medicare contributions. The loss of these protections has real costs: For example, a typical construction worker misclassified as an independent contractor would lose as much as $20,399 in annual income and job benefits compared with what they would have earned as an employee.
The Trump Department of Labor is currently finalizing a regulation that would narrow the definition of who qualifies as an employee under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The new rule will encourage a race to the bottom, as employers will find it much easier to just classify workers as independent contractors and evade their obligations to workers. EPI estimates that workers stand to lose over $3.7 billion annually in pay and benefits due to the rise in misclassification from the new Trump rule, and that social insurance funds would lose at least $357 million annually from lost employer contributions.
Amid these threats, states can take a range of measures to maintain and strengthen labor standards and enforcement, including:
- Investigating the costs of misclassification to workers and social insurance funds. State-specific studies can help assess actual costs of misclassification, identify weak spots in existing state policy, and build urgency for taking targeted action to strengthen misclassification protections.
- Establishing a strong legal test—the ABC test—for determining employee status and pairing it with robust enforcement. The ABC test presumes that workers are employees, places the burden on the employer to prove otherwise, and provides a clear, narrow definition of independent contractor status.
- Implementing innovative strategies to strengthen workers’ right to proper classification, such as creating interagency task forces to more effectively crack down on misclassification in targeted industries.
The policy brief is part of EPI’s “Holding the Line” series that provides state solutions to the U.S. workers’ rights crisis. Previous installments in the series have outlined how state policymakers can boost minimum wage standards, expand union and collective bargaining rights, and strengthen child labor standards.