A Brief but Sad History of Selected Corporate Inversions
Earlier this week, we were greeted with the news that Burger King, a U.S. fast-food giant, is in talks to merge with Tim Hortons, a much smaller Canadian fast-food chain, and become a Canadian firm. This proposed deal is interesting on many levels. First, it is another example of a corporate inversion in which, to use Edward Kleinbard’s description, a “foreign minnow swallows a domestic whale.”
Second and more importantly, this is a corporate inversion involving a large U.S. corporation and a much smaller foreign corporation that was once a U.S. corporation. Yes, you read that correctly: Tim Hortons was a U.S. corporation prior to its inversion to Canada in 2009. Though to be fair, Tim Hortons started as a Canadian company—it was founded in Hamilton, Ontario in 1964. Wendy’s restaurant chain purchased Tim Hortons in 1995 and then spun-off the company in 2006. Tim Hortons inverted to Canada in 2009 arguing that they had substantial business activity in Canada.
This is not the first instance of a U.S. multinational seeking to become a foreign firm by purchasing a foreign firm that was once a U.S. firm. Ohio-based Eaton Corp “moved” to Ireland in 2012 by acquiring Cooper Industries. Cooper Industries, however, was a Texas-based company until it inverted in 2002 to Bermuda, a well-known tax haven; its administrative headquarters, however, remained in Texas. Worried that proposed antitax-haven legislation would designate many firms located in tax havens as U.S. corporations for tax purposes, Cooper Industries again “moved” in 2009, this time to Ireland.
Medtronic, a Minnesota-based medical device manufacturer, is shifting its home to Ireland by buying Covidien, an Irish medical device maker. What is not well known is Covidien was, until 1997, a U.S. corporation known as Tyco Healthcare and part of Tyco International. In 1997, New Jersey-based Tyco inverted to Bermuda. After the Tyco CEO Dennis Kozlowski was dumped (and eventually convicted of grand larceny), the new Tyco management spun-off Tyco Healthcare as Covidien. In 2010, Covidien relocated to Ireland, apparently for the same reason as Cooper Industries.
A sad part of inversion stories is the U.S. tax code allows U.S. corporations to move their tax home to a tax haven by merging with a small foreign firm and keep their administrative headquarters in the U.S. But sadder still is the U.S. tax code also allows this kind of merger to be with a “foreign” firm that has its administrative headquarters in the United States and used to be a U.S. corporation—U.S. corporations are becoming foreign corporations by merging with ostensibly U.S. corporations! The time is certainly ripe for Congress to revisit the anti-inversion rules put into the tax code in 2004 to prevent further erosion of the corporate tax base.
Enjoyed this post?
Sign up for EPI's newsletter so you never miss our research and insights on ways to make the economy work better for everyone.