Every state will lose jobs as a result of the coronavirus: Policymakers must take action

Workers across the country have already lost their jobs as businesses temporarily shutter in response to the social distancing measures necessary to stop the spread of coronavirus—a trend which can be mitigated if policymakers act quickly. Expectations of just how many jobs will be lost are rapidly evolving. Goldman Sachs forecasts that the economy will contract by 2.5% over the first half of this year—which we estimate will translate into a loss of 3 million jobs by June. An even bleaker forecast from Deutsche Bank, which is in line with projections from JPMorgan, suggests that 7.5 million jobs will be lost by the summer. In this post, we attempt to predict the state-level impacts of these losses using the midpoint of these two forecasts—an estimated 5.25 million jobs lost.

We have distributed this projected job loss across states to provide a sense of the magnitude of the state-level shock, shown in Figure A. The coronavirus shock that is causing this recession is broad-based; the effects will likely be felt in every industry and geography. Still, workers in certain industries will be disproportionately affected—in particular, workers in food service, accommodations, and brick-and-mortar retail. As a result, states where these industries make up a larger share of employment, such as Florida, Hawaii, and Nevada, will be particularly hard hit. In Nevada, where two out of every five jobs are in leisure, hospitality, or retail, the state will likely lose 5.3% of private-sector jobs.

Figure A

Estimated jobs lost due to coronavirus by summer 2020, by state

State Projected job loss as a share of total private-sector employment Projected job loss Leisure, hospitality, and retail as a share of total private-sector employment
Alabama 4.2% 70,159 26.1%
Alaska 4.4% 10,946 28.7%
Arizona 4.2% 104,914 26.1%
Arkansas 4.0% 42,659 24.1%
California 4.1% 603,741 24.9%
Colorado 4.2% 97,912 26.5%
Connecticut 3.9% 56,735 22.9%
Delaware 4.2% 16,727 26.4%
Washington D.C. 3.6% 19,996 18.7%
Florida 4.5% 352,753 30.2%
Georgia 4.1% 161,334 25.4%
Hawaii 5.1% 26,926 37.3%
Idaho 4.2% 26,819 27.0%
Illinois 3.9% 206,648 22.8%
Indiana 3.9% 107,271 23.0%
Iowa 4.0% 53,117 24.1%
Kansas 4.0% 45,995 23.4%
Kentucky 4.1% 66,777 25.3%
Louisiana 4.3% 71,452 27.8%
Maine 4.3% 23,114 28.0%
Maryland 4.1% 92,046 24.8%
Massachusetts 3.9% 125,432 22.5%
Michigan 4.0% 151,316 23.5%
Minnesota 3.9% 98,487 22.3%
Mississippi 4.5% 40,929 29.7%
Missouri 4.1% 100,343 24.9%
Montana 4.6% 18,230 31.8%
Nebraska 3.9% 33,702 23.4%
Nevada 5.3% 66,656 40.2%
New Hampshire 4.3% 25,726 28.1%
New Jersey 4.0% 142,223 23.5%
New Mexico 4.3% 29,016 28.2%
New York 3.9% 322,494 22.6%
North Carolina 4.2% 161,363 26.5%
North Dakota 4.0% 14,290 24.2%
Ohio 3.9% 189,518 23.4%
Oklahoma 4.2% 56,213 26.0%
Oregon 4.1% 68,104 25.8%
Pennsylvania 3.8% 206,169 22.1%
Rhode Island 4.1% 17,771 24.7%
South Carolina 4.4% 79,802 28.8%
South Dakota 4.3% 15,402 27.3%
Tennessee 4.1% 110,670 25.5%
Texas 4.1% 442,717 25.1%
Utah 4.1% 53,452 25.1%
Vermont 4.4% 11,334 28.5%
Virginia 4.0% 134,663 24.6%
Washington 4.1% 119,145 25.6%
West Virginia 4.3% 24,255 27.3%
Wisconsin 3.9% 100,149 22.6%
Wyoming 4.5% 9,850 29.7%

Note: Map shows employment loss consistent with a Goldman Sachs March 15 forecast of GDP growth for the first half of 2020, which assumed moderate stimulus measures are taken. Subsequent projections by other forecasters predict even steeper GDP losses that would translate into greater job losses.

Source: Economic Policy Institute analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Employment data and Goldman Sachs and Deutsche Bank growth forecasts, as calculated in Josh Bivens, “Coronavirus Shock Will Likely Claim 3 Million Jobs by Summer,” Working Economics, March 17, 2020.

Copy the code below to embed this chart on your website.

This disproportionate impact matters for our estimation of job loss by state. To capture both the expansive effects of this recession and the outsize impact on the leisure, hospitality, and retail industries, we provide three measures of projected state job loss: one that distributes the national estimate based on each state’s share of total private employment; one based instead on their share of leisure, hospitality, and retail employment; and the average of those two measures. Figure A displays the average measure and Table 1 shows all three job-loss projections. Both the figure and table also show the leisure, hospitality, and retail industries’ share of private-sector employment and the projected job losses as a share of private-sector employment in each state. The data presented here reflect our most recent total job-loss estimate of 5.25 million. As our understanding of the situation evolves, you can use our methodology to distribute other estimates of total job loss across states by inputing a national estimate into this spreadsheet.

Table 1

Estimated jobs lost due to coronavirus by summer 2020, by state

Projected job loss
State Based on share of total private-sector employment Based on share of leisure, hospitality, and retail employment Average of columns (1) and (2) Leisure, hospitality, and retail as a share of total private-sector employment Projected job loss as a share of total private-sector employment
United States 5,250,000 5,250,000 5,250,000 25.1% 4.1%
 Alabama 68,753 71,564 70,159 26.1% 4.2%
 Alaska 10,210 11,683 10,946 28.7% 4.4%
 Arizona 102,872 106,955 104,914 26.1% 4.2%
 Arkansas 43,572 41,746 42,659 24.1% 4.0%
 California 606,094 601,387 603,741 24.9% 4.1%
 Colorado 95,321 100,503 97,912 26.5% 4.2%
 Connecticut 59,325 54,146 56,735 22.9% 3.9%
 Delaware 16,313 17,142 16,727 26.4% 4.2%
 Washington D.C. 22,899 17,093 19,996 18.7% 3.6%
 Florida 320,262 385,244 352,753 30.2% 4.5%
 Georgia 160,491 162,176 161,334 25.4% 4.1%
 Hawaii 21,655 32,197 26,926 37.3% 5.1%
 Idaho 25,856 27,782 26,819 27.0% 4.2%
 Illinois 216,494 196,802 206,648 22.8% 3.9%
 Indiana 111,953 102,588 107,271 23.0% 3.9%
 Iowa 54,207 52,027 53,117 24.1% 4.0%
 Kansas 47,573 44,418 45,995 23.4% 4.0%
 Kentucky 66,569 66,986 66,777 25.3% 4.1%
 Louisiana 67,804 75,100 71,452 27.8% 4.3%
 Maine 21,851 24,376 23,114 28.0% 4.3%
 Maryland 92,535 91,557 92,046 24.8% 4.1%
 Massachusetts 132,226 118,638 125,432 22.5% 3.9%
 Michigan 156,229 146,404 151,316 23.5% 4.0%
 Minnesota 104,357 92,616 98,487 22.3% 3.9%
 Mississippi 37,489 44,369 40,929 29.7% 4.5%
 Missouri 100,835 99,851 100,343 24.9% 4.1%
 Montana 16,076 20,384 18,230 31.8% 4.6%
 Nebraska 34,912 32,491 33,702 23.4% 3.9%
 Nevada 51,238 82,074 66,656 40.2% 5.3%
 New Hampshire 24,289 27,162 25,726 28.1% 4.3%
 New Jersey 146,808 137,637 142,223 23.5% 4.0%
 New Mexico 27,333 30,698 29,016 28.2% 4.3%
 New York 339,389 305,598 322,494 22.6% 3.9%
 North Carolina 157,145 165,582 161,363 26.5% 4.2%
 North Dakota 14,566 14,013 14,290 24.2% 4.0%
 Ohio 196,377 182,658 189,518 23.4% 3.9%
 Oklahoma 55,234 57,193 56,213 26.0% 4.2%
 Oregon 67,154 69,055 68,104 25.8% 4.1%
 Pennsylvania 219,137 193,201 206,169 22.1% 3.8%
 Rhode Island 17,929 17,614 17,771 24.7% 4.1%
 South Carolina 74,337 85,268 79,802 28.8% 4.4%
 South Dakota 14,754 16,050 15,402 27.3% 4.3%
 Tennessee 109,822 111,518 110,670 25.5% 4.1%
 Texas 442,981 442,453 442,717 25.1% 4.1%
 Utah 53,475 53,429 53,452 25.1% 4.1%
 Vermont 10,611 12,058 11,334 28.5% 4.4%
 Virginia 136,120 133,205 134,663 24.6% 4.0%
 Washington 117,876 120,414 119,145 25.6% 4.1%
 West Virginia 23,222 25,289 24,255 27.3% 4.3%
 Wisconsin 105,351 94,946 100,149 22.6% 3.9%
 Wyoming 9,028 10,673 9,850 29.7% 4.5%

Source: Economic Policy Institute analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Employment data and Goldman Sachs and Deutsche Bank growth forecasts, as calculated in Josh Bivens, “Coronavirus Shock Will Likely Claim 3 Million Jobs by Summer,” Working Economics, March 17, 2020.

Copy the code below to embed this chart on your website.

State policymakers must play a critical role in responding to this crisis. They can take steps now that will reduce job losses and mitigate harm to unemployed and other vulnerable populations, while an adequate federal response is worked out. For example, they can expand access to unemployment insurance (UI) by waiving job-search requirements and waiting periods, bolster direct income support programs such as Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF), increase funding for direct service providers such as homeless shelters and food banks, and use their emergency powers to place a moratorium on evictions and utility shut-offs. Stopping a recession at this point is likely impossible, but actions such as these can soften the blow and help many whose lives are already being upended.